8–8 · #3 in AFC SouthChoose season
| Player | Pos | # | College | Debut | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Adam Vinatieri | K | — | — | — | Active |
| Akeem Ayers | LB | — | — | 2011 | Active |
| Andrew Luck | QB | — | — | 2012 | Active |
| Anthony Castonzo | OT | — | — | 2011 | Active |
| Antonio Cromartie | CB | — | — | 2006 | Active |
| Antonio Morrison | ILB | — | — | 2016 | Active |
| Arthur Jones | DT | — | — | 2011 | Active |
| Austin Blythe | C | — | — | 2016 | Active |
| Charles James | DB | — | — | 2013 | Active |
| Chase Coffman | TE | — | — | 2010 | Active |
| Chester Rogers | WR | — | — | 2016 | Active |
| Chris Carter | LB | — | — | 2011 | Active |
| Chris Milton | CB | — | — | 2016 | Active |
| Clayton Geathers | S | — | — | 2015 | Active |
| Curt Maggitt | OLB | — | — | 2016 | Active |
| D'Qwell Jackson | ILB | — | — | 2006 | Active |
| Darius Butler | FS | — | — | 2009 | Active |
| Darryl Morris | DB | — | — | 2013 | Active |
| David Parry | DT | — | — | 2015 | Active |
| Deiontrez Mount | LB | — | — | 2015 | Active |
| Denzelle Good | G | — | — | 2015 | Active |
| Deon King | LB | — | — | 2016 | Active |
| Devin Street | WR | — | — | 2014 | Active |
| Donte Moncrief | WR | — | — | 2014 | Active |
| Duke Williams | S | — | — | 2013 | Active |
| Dwayne Allen | TE | — | — | 2012 | Active |
| Edwin Jackson | ILB | — | — | 2016 | Active |
| Erik Swoope | TE | — | — | 2015 | Active |
| Erik Walden | LB | — | — | 2008 | Active |
| Frank Gore | RB | — | — | 2005 | Active |
| Frankie Williams | CB | — | — | 2016 | Active |
| Hassan Ridgeway | DT | — | — | 2016 | Active |
| Henry Anderson | DE | — | — | 2015 | Active |
| Jack Doyle | TE | — | — | 2013 | Active |
| Jack Mewhort | G | — | — | 2014 | Active |
| Jeremy Vujnovich | G | — | — | 2016 | Active |
| Joe Haeg | OT | — | — | 2016 | Active |
| Joe Reitz | OT | — | — | 2011 | Active |
| Jonotthan Harrison | C | — | — | 2014 | Active |
| Jordan Todman | RB | — | — | 2012 | Active |
| Josh Ferguson | RB | — | — | 2016 | Active |
| Josh McNary | ILB | — | — | 2013 | Active |
| Kendall Langford | DE | — | — | 2008 | Active |
| Lavar Edwards | LB | — | — | 2013 | Active |
| Le'Raven Clark | OT | — | — | 2016 | Active |
| Luke Rhodes | LS | — | — | 2016 | Active |
| Matt Overton | LS | — | — | 2012 | Active |
| Matthias Farley | DB | — | — | 2016 | Active |
| Mike Adams | FS | — | — | 2004 | Active |
| Patrick McAfee | P | — | — | 2009 | Active |
| Patrick Robinson | CB | — | — | 2010 | Active |
| Phillip Dorsett | WR | — | — | 2015 | Active |
| Quan Bray | WR | — | — | 2015 | Active |
| Rashaan Melvin | CB | — | — | 2014 | Active |
| Robert Mathis | OLB | — | — | 2003 | Active |
| Robert Turbin | RB | — | — | 2012 | Active |
| Ryan Kelly | C | — | — | 2016 | Active |
| Scott Tolzien | QB | — | — | 2013 | Active |
| Sio Moore | OLB | — | — | 2013 | Active |
| T.J. Green | DB | — | — | 2016 | Active |
| T.Y. Hilton | WR | — | — | 2012 | Active |
| T.Y. McGill | DT | — | — | 2015 | Active |
| Tevaun Smith | WR | — | — | 2016 | Active |
| Trent Cole | OLB | — | — | 2005 | Active |
| Trevor Bates | LB | — | — | 2016 | Active |
| Vontae Davis | CB | — | — | 2009 | Active |
| Winston Guy | FS | — | — | 2013 | Active |
| Zach Kerr | DE | — | — | 2014 | Active |
| 3–1 |
| .750 |
| -14 |
| 2–2 | .500 | +12 |
| 2–2 | .500 | -10 |
| Team | W–L–T | PCT | DIFF |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3–1 | .750 | +51 | |
| 2–2 | .500 | -2 | |
| 0–4 | .000 | -25 | |
| 0–4 | .000 | -28 |
| Team | W–L–T | PCT | DIFF |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4–0 | 1.000 | +41 | |
| 3–1 | .750 | +31 | |
| 2–2 | .500 | -20 | |
| 0–4 | .000 | -39 |
| Team | W–L–T | PCT | DIFF |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3–1 | .750 | +3 | |
| 2–2 | .500 | +10 | |
| 2–2 | .500 | -18 | |
| 1–3 | .250 | -34 |
| Team | W–L–T | PCT | DIFF |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4–0 | 1.000 | +35 | |
| 3–1 | .750 | +47 | |
| 2–2 | .500 | -8 | |
| 2–2 | .500 | -32 |
| Team | W–L–T | PCT | DIFF |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2–2 | .500 | +12 | |
| 2–2 | .500 | +4 | |
| 1–3 | .250 | -23 | |
| 0–4 | .000 | -20 |
| Team | W–L–T | PCT | DIFF |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4–0 | 1.000 | +58 | |
| 3–1 | .750 | +32 | |
| 2–2 | .500 | +2 | |
| 1–3 | .250 | -30 |