6–10 · #4 in AFC EastChoose season
| Player | Pos | # | College | Debut | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aaron Berry | DB | — | — | 2010 | Active |
| Aaron Maybin | LB | — | — | 2009 | Active |
| Antonio Allen | DB | — | — | 2012 | Active |
| Antonio Cromartie | CB | — | — | 2006 | Active |
| Austin Howard | OT | — | — | 2012 | Active |
| Bart Scott | ILB | — | — | 2002 | Active |
| Bilal Powell | RB | — | — | 2011 | Active |
| Brandon Moore | G | — | — | 2004 | Active |
| Braylon Edwards | WR | — | — | 2005 | Active |
| Bryan Thomas | OLB | — | — | 2002 | Active |
| Calvin Pace | OLB | — | — | 2003 | Active |
| Chaz Schilens | WR | — | — | 2008 | Active |
| Clyde Gates | WR | — | — | 2011 | Active |
| D'Brickashaw Ferguson | OT | — | — | 2006 | Active |
| Daniel Muir | DT | — | — | 2007 | Active |
| Darrelle Revis | DB | — | — | 2007 | Active |
| Darrin Walls | CB | — | — | 2011 | Active |
| David Harris | OLB | — | — | 2007 | Active |
| Dedrick Epps | TE | — | — | 2012 | Active |
| Demario Davis | OLB | — | — | 2012 | Active |
| Dustin Keller | TE | — | — | 2008 | Active |
| Ellis Lankster | DB | — | — | 2009 | Active |
| Eric Smith | FS | — | — | 2006 | Active |
| Garrett McIntyre | OLB | — | — | 2011 | Active |
| Greg McElroy | QB | — | — | 2012 | Active |
| Hayden Smith | TE | — | — | 2012 | Active |
| Isaiah Trufant | DB | — | — | 2010 | Active |
| Jason Hill | WR | — | — | 2007 | Active |
| Jason Smith | OT | — | — | 2009 | Active |
| Jeff Cumberland | TE | — | — | 2010 | Active |
| Jeremy Kerley | WR | — | — | 2011 | Active |
| Joe McKnight | RB | — | — | 2010 | Active |
| John Conner | FB | — | — | 2010 | Active |
| Jonathan Grimes | RB | — | — | 2012 | Active |
| Jordan White | WR | — | — | 2012 | Active |
| Josh Bush | FS | — | — | 2012 | Active |
| Josh Mauga | ILB | — | — | 2010 | Active |
| Kahlil Bell | RB | — | — | 2009 | Active |
| Kenrick Ellis | DT | — | — | 2011 | Active |
| Konrad Reuland | TE | — | — | 2012 | Active |
| Kyle Wilson | DB | — | — | 2010 | Active |
| LaRon Landry | FS | — | — | 2007 | Active |
| Lex Hilliard | FB | — | — | 2009 | Active |
| Marcus Dixon | DE | — | — | 2010 | Active |
| Marcus Dowtin | LB | — | — | 2012 | Active |
| Mardy Gilyard | WR | — | — | 2010 | Active |
| Mark Sanchez | QB | — | — | 2009 | Active |
| Matt Slauson | G | — | — | 2010 | Active |
| Mike DeVito | DE | — | — | 2007 | Active |
| Muhammad Wilkerson | DE | — | — | 2011 | Active |
| Nick Bellore | LB | — | — | 2011 | Active |
| Nick Folk | K | — | — | 2007 | Active |
| Nick Mangold | C | — | — | 2006 | Active |
| Patrick Turner | WR | — | — | 2009 | Active |
| Quinton Coples | OLB | — | — | 2012 | Active |
| Robert Malone | P | — | — | 2010 | Active |
| Santonio Holmes | WR | — | — | 2006 | Active |
| Shonn Greene | RB | — | — | 2009 | Active |
| Sione Po'uha | NT | — | — | 2005 | Active |
| Stephen Hill | WR | — | — | 2012 | Active |
| Tanner Purdum | LS | — | — | 2011 | Active |
| Tim Tebow | QB | — | — | 2010 | Active |
| Vladimir Ducasse | G | — | — | 2011 | Active |
| Yeremiah Bell | S | — | — | 2004 | Active |
| 3–1 |
| .750 |
| -14 |
| 2–2 | .500 | +12 |
| 2–2 | .500 | -10 |
| Team | W–L–T | PCT | DIFF |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3–1 | .750 | +51 | |
| 2–2 | .500 | -2 | |
| 0–4 | .000 | -25 | |
| 0–4 | .000 | -28 |
| Team | W–L–T | PCT | DIFF |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4–0 | 1.000 | +41 | |
| 3–1 | .750 | +31 | |
| 2–2 | .500 | -20 | |
| 0–4 | .000 | -39 |
| Team | W–L–T | PCT | DIFF |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3–1 | .750 | +3 | |
| 2–2 | .500 | +10 | |
| 2–2 | .500 | -18 | |
| 1–3 | .250 | -34 |
| Team | W–L–T | PCT | DIFF |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4–0 | 1.000 | +35 | |
| 3–1 | .750 | +47 | |
| 2–2 | .500 | -8 | |
| 2–2 | .500 | -32 |
| Team | W–L–T | PCT | DIFF |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2–2 | .500 | +12 | |
| 2–2 | .500 | +4 | |
| 1–3 | .250 | -23 | |
| 0–4 | .000 | -20 |
| Team | W–L–T | PCT | DIFF |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4–0 | 1.000 | +58 | |
| 3–1 | .750 | +32 | |
| 2–2 | .500 | +2 | |
| 1–3 | .250 | -30 |